I loved the liner, it is high pigmented and lasts all day which is a rare find. The remover really helped me remove the liner and my lash glue so that all I needed to do was wipe it off gently. But I'm going to complain about the adhesive portion of the liner. I really did not stick last a couple of hours. I was mad, but I emailed customer service and was told if I needed a tighter hold to use lash glue on the inner corner and end of the lash. This worked, but the point was to not have to use glue anymore, right?